Pilot

S1: E1 Airdate: 8.15.11

Two Identical twins trade their radically different lives so one can investigate who separated them at birth.

Being Sutton

S1: E2 Airdate: 8.22.11

Emma worries that her questionable ballroom dancing skills will expose her at the father-daughter dance.

Double Dibs

S1: E3 Airdate: 8.29.11

Sutton tracks down the family that originally adopted Emma in Los Angeles.

Twinsense and Sensibility

S1: E4 Airdate: 9.5.11

Emma has a recurring childhood nightmare that might be the clue Sutton needs to find their birth mother.

Over Exposed

S1: E5 Airdate: 9.12.11

In a very un-Sutton-like move, Emma drops out of the Homecoming Queen race, but Char and Mads won’t let her quit.

Bad Boys Break Hearts

S1: E6 Airdate: 9.19.11

Ethan breaks up with Sutton to be with Emma, and Sutton’s jealousy begins to set in.

Escape from Sutton Island

S1: E7 Airdate: 9.26.11

Sutton comes face-to-face with her mother…only to find even more skeletons in the family’s closet.

Never Have I Ever

S1: E8 Airdate: 10.3.11

Emma’s foster brother shows up from Las Vegas and threatens to expose her secret.

Sex, Lies and Hard Knocks High

S1: E9 Airdate: 10.10.11

Sutton is forced to go to Las Vegas and take on Emma’s identity after being mistakenly recognized.

East of Emma

S1: E10 Airdate: 10.17.11

Emma struggles to keep the secret alive when the Mercers throw her a lavish birthday party.

O Twin, Where Art Thou?

S1: E11 Airdate: 1.2.12

Sutton returns to Phoenix but goes missing after a heated argument between her, Emma and Ethan.

When We Dead Awaken

S1: E12 Airdate: 1.9.12

Emma begins to live in fear of her sister after receiving a mysterious package believed to be from Sutton.

Pleased to Meet Me

S1: E13 Airdate: 1.16.12

Emma, Ethan and Thayer investigate what happened to Sutton the night she went missing.

Black and White and Green All Over

S1: E14 Airdate: 1.23.12

Sutton surprises everyone by showing up to the country club’s Back and White Ball.

Dead Man Talking

S1: E15 Airdate: 1.30.12

A tattoo that sparks Ethan’s memory about Sutton could unravel everything.

No Country For Young Love

S1: E17 Airdate: 2.13.12

Emma, Mads and Thayer tirelessly search for leads to prove Ethan’s innocence.

Not Guilty As Charged

S1: E18 Airdate: 2.20.12

Encouraged by their time together in hiding, Sutton makes a move on Ethan.

Weekend of Living Dangerously

S1: E19 Airdate: 2.27.12

Thayer begins to suspect that his father is behind Derek’s murder and investigates his alibi.

Unholy Matrimony

S1: E20 Airdate: 3.5.12

Ethan uncovers a secret that sends shockwaves through the Mercer household.