BLACKMAIL AND COUGARS — Ryan (Noah Reid) is obsessed with finding his fiancée Beth, so he and Brandon (Dillon Casey) reach out to Beth’s family to locate her travel itinerary. They quickly find themselves at Beth’s younger brother Randall’s (guest star John Paul Ruttan) mercy when he demands payment in the form of topless photos before handing over any info. The guys head to a beach on the Amalfi Coast and spot Isabella Cucinota (guest star Maria Cristina Heller), the screen siren of Brandon’s childhood dreams. Ryan wants to stay focused on getting a topless photo for Beth’s brother, but Brandon can’t say no when Isabella invites the guys back to her place. Josh Levi directed the episode written by Adam M. Reid & Max B. Reid.